When preparing highly skilled nurses for testimony in  medical malpractice litigation, it's essential to address emotional and psychological factors that may affect their performance. Legal proceedings present unique challenges for these professionals, highlighting the need for careful and tailored witness preparation to ensure they can effectively testify at deposition.

A common approach should include helping nurses differentiate between clinical standards and legal definitions, deprogramming them from their innate safety-focused responses, and conducting a psychological assessment early in the process to identify and address any underlying anxiety, anger, or guilt that may affect their testimony.

What special considerations must be taken when preparing highly-trained nurses for testimony?

Given their strong dedication to patient care and the possible sense of betrayal they may experience when their actions are questioned, more care must be taken to address the emotional and psychological state of highly-trained nurses before they testify. Legal teams must tailor their approach based on the nurse's role, ensuring that lower-level nurses receive reassurance and confidence-building while higher-level nurses understand the importance of speaking only to their legal scope of practice. 

Understanding the Emotional Landscape of a Nurse Witness

Highly trained nurses, including registered nurses (RNs), nurse practitioners (NPs), and nurse managers, are at the forefront of patient care. They often serve as the primary point of contact in a hospital or clinical setting, and due to this, their careers mainly consist of building close relationships with their patients. 

The legal process, where their actions are questioned, can be particularly difficult for nurses because of their emotional investment. Learning that their care is being scrutinized, particularly by the patients or families with whom they have developed strong bonds, can feel like a deep betrayal. A nurse’s emotional affect can manifest in various ways, including anger, guilt, or anxiety. 

For instance, a nurse who feels guilty about an adverse outcome may be more likely to admit fault, even when their care was appropriate. Alternatively, a nurse who is angry or defensive may come across as combative, which can be detrimental to their credibility. Legal teams must be aware of these feelings and take appropriate action while preparing the nurse for deposition. 

Tailor the Legal Approach Based on the Nurse’s Role

A nurse’s approach to testifying is significantly impacted by their level of training and responsibility. For example, Licensed Practical Nurses (LPNs) and Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) may experience higher levels of fear and anxiety due to their relative lack of experience and perception that their jobs are on the line. Preparing entry-level nurses for testimony might require additional assurance and support to strengthen their confidence.

On the other hand, Nurse Practitioners and Nurse Managers, who have extensive training and often work closely with physicians, may face different challenges. Although these nurses are more likely to feel secure in their clinical judgment, they could find it difficult to remain in their legal "lane". Those who frequently make critical decisions in a clinical context may find it tempting to offer advice outside their medical expertise.

Start with a Psychological Assessment

One of the most effective tools in preparing highly-trained nurses for testimony is conducting a psychological assessment early in the preparation process. Asking nurses to rate their levels of anger, anxiety, and guilt on a scale from 0 to 10 can provide invaluable insights into their emotional state. This simple yet powerful exercise allows legal teams to tailor their approach based on the nurse’s emotional landscape.

For instance, if a nurse reports high anxiety, attorneys can focus on how to boost their self-esteem and assist with stress management. If a nurse is dealing with significant guilt, it may be necessary to delve into the specifics of their care and allow them to objectively assess their actions to alleviate undue self-blame. Addressing these emotions in preparation ensures they do not surface unexpectedly during testimony, which could compromise the nurse’s performance.

Medical Hierarchies Affect Litigation Dynamics

The medical industry's hierarchical structure is frequently evident during legal proceedings. Higher-ranking nurses, in particular, could find themselves in the middle of a "turf war" between the legal teams representing various parties, such as the hospital and physicians. This dynamic can bring to the surface the everyday frustrations nurses experience in their work environment, where they may feel their voices are not always heard or respected.

The deposition and courtroom preparation process should include training that addresses these dynamics in detail and prepares the nurse witnesses to manage their emotional responses. For instance, a nurse can experience severe emotional distress if they learn that a physician or colleague has criticized their treatment. Attorneys, when preparing highly-trained nurses for testimony, must be ready for such revelations and help them develop strategies to remain composed and professional.

The Importance of Emotional Deprogramming

Nurses are highly trained to prioritize patient safety, and this training is constantly reinforced throughout their careers. While this focus on safety is essential in their clinical work, it can make them particularly susceptible to reptile tactics during testimony, where opposing counsel may use safety-related questions to trick nurse witnesses into admissions that support the plaintiff’s case.

To mitigate this, it is necessary to "deprogram" nurses from their instinctual responses and reframe their understanding of patient safety within the legal context. As part of this process, they will be assisted in differentiating between clinical safety requirements and the legal definitions of responsibility or negligence. By doing this, nurses can stay clear of the trap of answering broad, leading questions that, while they might seem appropriate given their training, could end up backfiring in a legal situation.

Strategies for Keeping Highly-Trained Nurses in the Legal Lane

For highly-trained nurses, particularly Nurse Practitioners, staying within their legal lane can be challenging. These professionals are used to making complex decisions and might be tempted to offer explanations or justifications beyond what is necessary. It might be difficult for highly skilled nurses, especially Nurse Practitioners, to remain in their legal "lanes". To prevent nurses from providing more explanations or arguments than required, it is important to emphasize the importance of owning their actions without over-explaining or justifying, particularly at deposition.

Training sessions should focus on helping nurses understand when to stop talking and resist the urge to pivot or defend themselves unnecessarily. Encouraging them to stick to the facts and trust in their documented care can prevent them from inadvertently making statements that could be used against them. Explanations for the decisions made or actions taken or not taken should be held for trial when the defense attorney can ask questions in the appropriate way.

Witness Preparation for Highly-Trained Nurses

Preparing highly-trained nurses for testimony is a multifaceted process that requires a deep understanding of the emotional and psychological challenges these professionals face. 

Legal teams can help ensure that nurses present their testimony confidently and effectively by working with experts trained to address these challenges head-on and tailoring the preparation process to the nurse’s role and emotional state. 

Whether dealing with the emotional fallout of being criticized by colleagues or getting help to stay within their legal lanes, well-prepared nurses are better equipped to navigate the complexities of the legal system.

Courtroom Sciences helps attorneys efficiently navigate litigation by providing psychological expertise, science-backed data, and expert support for all phases of litigation. Learn how CSI's litigation consulting experts can improve outcomes for your next case. Speak with one of our experts to get started.

Key Takeaways:

●  Addressing the emotional and psychological state of highly-trained nurses is crucial, as their deep investment in patient care can lead to feelings of guilt, anger, or anxiety during testimony.

●  Legal preparation must be tailored to the nurse’s role.

●  Nurses can be "deprogrammed" from their instinctual safety-focused responses to avoid reptile tactics used by opposing counsel during deposition questioning.

●  Conducting an early psychological assessment to gauge levels of anger, anxiety, and guilt helps the preparation process address the nurse’s emotional needs.

●  The hierarchical structure of the medical field can lead to internal conflicts during testimony, making it essential to prepare nurses for potential criticism from colleagues or physicians.

●  Attorneys can encourage nurses to focus on facts to avoid harmful statements during testimony.